Im talking about writing against culture abulughod 1991. Honor and poetry in a bedouin society and writing womens worlds. Abulughod lila abulughod ethics forum september 11 and. Writing against culture friday, 11 december 2015, 6. It was published by columbia university press in april 2007. Download for offline reading, highlight, bookmark or take notes while you read do muslim women need saving. This goes against what one would normally think because of his role in the community and the need to pass on his. In this analytical paper, lughod looks at women in. As the new teller of these tales abulughod draws on anthropological and feminist insights to construct a critical ethnography.
We must try to abandon this concept, she prescribes, by writing against culture. Further reproduction prohibited without permission. Finally, inspired by lila abulughods seminal article writing against culture, the. In the century before the black death swept across the developed world, economic relations flourished between europe, the middle east, and asia. No part of this excerpt may be reproduced or reprinted without permission in writing from the publisher. Neverthe less, i was not prepared for the specific forms bedouin resistance was taking when i arrived in the late 1970s to begin fieldwork.
Does abulughod entirely reject the notion of culture. Lila abulughod mentions that the women from the bedouin community mostly wanted girls. What themes in the lives of the awlad ali does she imply she will discuss in the book. Anthropological reflections on cultural relativism and its others abstract this article explores the ethics of the current war on terrorism, asking whether anthropology, the discipline devoted to understanding and dealing with cultural difference, can provide us with critical. Those assumptions posit a muslim culture in which women are innocent victims trapped in arranged marriages, stoned for adultery and other sexual misdemeanors, murdered by their fathers and brothers for violating family honor, and generally denied the freedom to choose the lives they want to lead. Lila abulughods article titled, do muslim women really need saving. It offers a detailed, moving portrait of the actual experiences of ordinary muslim women, and of the contingencies with which they live. Writing from the perspective of british social anthropology, kuper 1999 traces.
Lila abulughod was born to palestinian academic ibrahim abulughod and american sociologist janet abulughod in 1952. Lila abulughod and brian larkin exhilarating, as each brought different insights to the shaping of the book. For this reason, it would behoove anthropologists to focus on the analysis of specific people rather than certain societies as wholes. But back to your question about the success of my efforts. One is quoted as saying, it is only the ignorant who prefer boys. The idea that we should work against the generalizations about society and culture that are. Professor lila abulughods most recent work is the seminal book. Indeed, remaking women is a radical challenge to any easy equation of modernity with progress, emancipation, and the empowerment of women. Lila abulughod agrees that it is time to take textuality seriously and considers strategies for writing against culture that aims at suppressing the very concept of culture from the social science literature.
Readings for writing womens worlds by lila abulughod preface september 11 1. Selfinterpretation, agency, and the objects of anthropology. Known for a method she calls writing against culture, which allows her to avoid generalisations and highlight the individuality of womens experiences, abulughod compellingly applies this approach in order to show the futility of blaming culture for the oppression of muslim women. She is is an american with palestinian and jewish ancestry who is professor of anthropology and womens and gender studies at columbia university in new york city. Writing culture clifford and marcus 1986, the collection that marked a major new form of critique of cultural. Sadi, it focuses on palestinian memory and the experience of expulsion. Speaking about anthropological theory lila abulughod t he history of anthropological theory is a history of debate. How does abulughod set you up for her position in the awlad ali bedouin. Abulughods arguments against culture backfire, and highlight its role. Buttenweiser professor of social science in the department of anthropology at columbia university in new york city.
An anthropologist who has been writing about arab women for thirty years, she delves into the predicaments of muslim women today, questioning whether generalizations about islamic culture can explain the hardships these women face and asking what motivates particular individuals and institutions to promote their rights. For example, when i returned from my first trip back to cairo. Basically, integration promotes specific imaginaries of culture, race and. New cross gate, queens road peckham free, please book your place we have selected writing against culture 1991 by lila abulughod for our second reading. Readings for writing womens worlds by lila abulughod. To ease these tensions, abulughod feels that anthropologists must adapt the technique of writing against culture, not as culture or in culture, because culture is defined by its current participants.
I am surprised by how easily people presume that muslim women do not have rights, writes lila abulughod at the start of her book, do muslim women need. Last but not least she is grateful for the continuing intellectual excitement provided by present and former students in the program in culture and media at nyu, in particular tom bikales, teja. Start studying abulughod do muslim women really need saving learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Locating ethnography lila abulughod, 2000 sage journals. As abulughod writes, gendered orientalism has taken on a new life and new forms in our feminist twenty. As abulughod writes, gendered orientalism has taken on a new life and new forms in our feminist twenty first century. Lila abulughod born 1952 is a palestinianamerican anthropologist.
Pdf lila abulughod, in theory in social and cultural. In the effort to join ethnographers seeking to build on abulughods 1991 attempts to engage in writing against culture, mahmood joined several scholars who have called for the need to shift. Theory and methods abulughod, lila, 1991 writing against culture. She obtained her phd from harvard university in 1984.
What do you think is the connection between muslim wearing the veil and. The contributors are lila abulughod, marilyn booth, deniz kandiyoti, khaled fahmy, mervat hatem, afsaneh najmabadi, omnia shakry, and zohreh t. She has written widely on women and gender in the middle east. September 11 and ethnographic responsibility do muslim women really need saving. Abulughods work is important in cultural geography not only because of her interrogation of the concept of culture itself, but because of her work bridging feminist. Writing womens worlds is abulughods telling of those stories. Abulughod is persistent in writing against culture and against anthropologys tendency to typify cultures through social scienti. Analysis of lila abulughods do muslim women really. Their combined citations are counted only for the first article. Lila abulughod is professor of anthropology and middle east studies at new york university. Speaking about anthropological theory lila abu lughod t he history of anthropological theory is a history of debate. As a result, abulughod aims to deconstruct popular characterisations of muslim women through a process of writing against culture, by which she endeavours to bring forces and influences other than culture to the fore. The introduction was so promising, and there were admittedly several flashes of insights scattered throughout, but overall, do muslim women need saving. Free, please book your place we have selected writing against culture 1991 by lila.
In her new preface, lila abulughod tells of the many emails she received from readers, mostly students, who wanted to know what happened to the individuals they had come to know through the book. Current intersections of epistemologies and representational practices. She has transcribed hours of womens conversations and organized the material around five major subjects. She specializes in ethnographic research in the arab world, and her seven books cover topics including sentiment and poetry, nationalism and media, gender politics and the politics of memory. Lila abulughod, writing against culture philpapers. What has most fascinated me about the debates is that they reveal how our thinking develops both as a process of argument within a discipline that has its own terms, methods, and parameters, and as a process funda. Lila abu lughod, in theory in social and cultural anthropology. Speaking about anthropological theory lila abulughod.
Abulughods stated aim is to articulate why prevailing western stereotypes about islam and about the arab world fail to capture the reality of muslim womens lives. Jose limon also writes against previous anthropologists who studied the same field from a. In what she calls writing against culture, abulughod has written an ethnography that preserves the voice of the bedouin women with whom she lived. In the effort to join ethnographers seeking to build on abulughods 1991 attempts to engage in writing against culture, mahmood joined several scholars who. It seems to me from your description that abulughod is acknowledging that the concept of culture has played an important role in combatting racism and other forms of discrimination based on the notion that differences are inbred.
500 652 283 1377 1385 676 1065 158 919 990 901 572 553 1486 806 959 1213 1524 765 1289 52 667 1584 1431 158 1046 1429 75 1408 726 1420